Wintergirls Book Blog-Brandon Roe

Title: Wintergirls

Author: Laurie Halse Anderson

Audience: 9th grade and up

Summary

Lia and Cassie used to the best of friends. When high school hit, they parted ways. Now Cassie is dead and Lia is very alone. Both of them had major eating disorders. Purging and starving themselves to the point of being hospitalized or, in Cassie’s case, death. Lia struggles with her desire to eat but believes that she has to under one hundred pounds in order to be attractive. She has overbearing parents that want the best for her but have really poor ways of showing it. They try to control her rather than talk to her. She feels like a prisoner all day, every day. Then Cassie’s ghost begins to haunt her and Lia believes she just might end up going over the edge.

Read Aloud: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VpnuobcGgpw&feature=feedu

Themes

Pressure is a major theme in this book. It’s not just your typical peer pressure either. A lot of it comes from the parents in this book. Lia’s parents are very successful and seem to be caught up in their own success and professional lives than to pay much attention to Lia except for when she makes a mistake. There is no positive reinforcement or really much love from either of them for most of the story. Her moth does eventually open up to her and admits how much she missed her when she moved out and that it was her own fault for pushing her daughter away.

Cassie’s parents aren’t seen very much throughout the story but it is mentioned that they didn’t seem to pay too much attention to her and when Cassie’s ghost talks about her father whistling at her swim meets, he spent more time on telling her what she did wrong rather than complimenting her.

Also there is the pressure from society of having to be perfect, slim, and have a 00 waistline.

Duality is another major theme that shows up in the writing of this novel. You see numerous thoughts of Lia’s that are in direct contrast to what she actually says. This shows the different sides of her. The real side and the fake side. The text has lines drawn through it as if to try and etch them out of Lia’s mind. She fights so hard to keep the real her bottled up.

Connections

I know many people who have parents that are too caught up in their own lives and endeavors to even worry about their kids. They ignore them until they do something wrong, then they get all the attention in world. Even though that attention is negative it at least gives these kids some connection to their parents. I felt like this may have been part of Lia’s problem. Yes, it was much bigger than just wanting attention. In fact, many times Lia just wanted to get away from them but she kept doing it because she developed a serious problem. At first it might have been a bit nice to see that her parents cared but then the problem grew and grew until she spiraled out of control.

Reaction

This book, while certainly not my favorite, was interesting nonetheless. I thought it did a fine job of showing a very big problem in the youth of today that many people are too afraid to tackle. These days, ad campaigns, television, and many other types of media all portray women as extremely thin and sexual. This instills a sense that all women need to look like this in order to be attractive and successful. Books like this show young women that it doesn’t have to be this way.

Reception

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jan/30/wintergirls-laurie-halse-anderson-review

The review at The Guardian found this book to be a very effective work of YAL. “It’s a book that will be around for many years. It may not be an original piece, as these tricks have been pulled before in teen fiction. Yet it pulls them off with more skill and effect than anything I have ever read.”

Advertisements

About brandonroe27

I'm a junior and English Major at WIU.
This entry was posted in Book Blogs. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Wintergirls Book Blog-Brandon Roe

  1. Brandon, Where’s your read aloud? I like that you bring up the relationship between the two girls and their parents. The relationship with parents is something that many teens could relate to. What do you think Halse Anderson is saying about parent/teen relationships and how these girls see themselves? What is the role of divorce in Lia’s story?

    • brandonroe27 says:

      Sorry Rebekah I did the read aloud but just forgot to attach it. It’s on there now. I think that Halse Anderson is trying to show how parent/teen relationships are a very tricky thing. You see some who try to just be friends and then you see other parents who are way too controlling. I think that both of her parents really do care about it her but instead of trying to just talk to her and listen to her they jump straight to control and just lay down the law. Also I think Halse Anderson is trying to show girls that while the magazines they read show women who are paper thin, it isn’t necessary or healthy to try and pursue this ridiculous dream of being so skinny you see every bone in your body. The role of divorce is a very important factor in Lia’s story. At times it seems she is pulled between her mother and step mother and doesn’t really know how to feel about either one. Sometimes she seems to get along with her step mother then she goes and changes her mind, same thing with her mother. It represents the confusion and anger that can grow within a child from a divorced couple.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s